Discussion about this post

User's avatar
David Sasaki's avatar

These questions about friendship are very much in the ether among my cohort. I got a lot out of Marisa Franco’s book “Platonic” about how the way we were raised affects our assumptions about friendship, and how we make friends. I liked the book so much that I’ve been making a point to listen to podcasts that feature her, including this great episode from an Atlantic podcast about making friends: https://www.theatlantic.com/podcasts/archive/2023/06/friends-flaking-on-plans-advice/674262/

She makes the distinction between friends — as in people we’re willing to make sacrifices for without them feeling like sacrifices — and people we enjoy spending time with. I appreciated the distinction. There are dozens, maybe hundreds, of people I enjoy spending time with. But there are only a dozen people or so who I have the energy, headspace, and motivation to be true friends. Sometimes the lines blur, and my moodiness can occasionally make me want to shuffle who is in which category, but still, I found it to be a useful distinction.

So what matters to me most about the dozen or so people in the “i’m committed, friends for life” category? I genuinely want them to be happy. And I want to feel that they genuinely want me to be happy. That sounds dumb and obvious, but I don’t think it’s so often the case — and that many friendships are built on competition and comparison as much as love and support. Like your friend Roy above, I really enjoyed this one. (George Michael’s Faith was my first CD and I remember that my mom was so scandalized when she first heard the lyrics of Father Figure. You couldn’t get away with those lyrics today!)

Expand full comment
Roy P.'s avatar

Damn you Ali! Your posts are so good, that I have to stop whatever I’m doing to read them. This one made me get off my exercise bike, sit down, read every word, then listen to Older (da bomb …does anyone say that anymore?). Thank you for this thoughtful and sensitive post, and Anisa is definitely rocking the jean jacket! Old Monk Rum? I’m reading Frederick Douglass: Prophet of Freedom by David Blight.

Expand full comment
4 more comments...

No posts